Wives of Joseph Smith and Wives of Brigham Young (chart)



Detail of Oliver Cowdery letter (to his brother, Warren), where he refers to Joseph Smith’s “dirty, nasty, filthy affair” with Fanny Alger.
Detail of Oliver Cowdery’s letter (to his brother, Warren), where he refers to Joseph Smith’s
“dirty, nasty, filthy affair” with Fanny Alger.
(For more information, see, “Sacred Marriage or Secret Affair?”)

Wives of Joseph Smith

The chart below contains information from the book, Nauvoo Polygamy: … “but we called it celestial marriage” by George D. Smith.a Although Fanny Alger is not included in the list by George Smith, Todd Compton lists her as Joseph Smith’s first plural wife in his book, In Sacred Loneliness.b In 1887, Andrew Jenson, assistant church historian, listed Fanny Alger as one of Smith’s first plural wives in The Historical Record.c Numbers in parentheses ( ) represent Compton’s list of Joseph’s plural wives. Asterisks * represent the twenty-seven plural wives on Jenson’s list.1

a George D. Smith, Nauvoo Polygamy, pp. 621-623
b Todd Compton, In Sacred Lonliness, pp. 4-6
c Andrew Jenson, The Historical Record, 1887, vol. vi, pp. 233-234

Number Name of Plural WifeMarriage DateAge:
Joseph / Wife
Emma HaleJan. 18, 182721 / 22
* (1) Fanny Algerearly 183327 / 16
1.
* (3)
Louisa Be[a]manApril 5, 184135 / 26
2.
* (4)
Mrs. Zina Diantha Huntington (Jacobs)Oct. 27, 184135 / 20
3.
* (5)
Mrs. Presendia Lathrop Huntington (Buell)Dec. 11, 184135 / 31
4.
(6)
Agnes Moulton Coolbirth (Smith)Jan. 6, 184236 / 30
5.
* (2)
Mrs. Lucinda Pendleton (Morgan Harris)after
Jan. 17, 1842
36 / 40
6.
* (8)
Mrs. Mary Elizabeth Rollins (Lightner)Feb. 184236 / 23
7.
* (7)
Mrs. Sylvia Porter Sessions (Lyon)Feb. 8, 184236 / 23
8.
(9)
Mrs. Patty Bartlett (Sessions)Mar. 9, 184236 / 47
9.
* (12)
Mrs. Sarah M. Kingsley (Howe Cleveland)after
March 1842
36 / 53
10.
(11)
Mrs. Elizabeth Davis (G. Brackenbury Durfee)after
March 1842
36 / 50
11.
(10)
Mrs. Marinda Nancy Johnson (Hyde)April 184236 / 26
12.
(13)
Delcena Diadamia Johnson (Sherman)approx.
Jun 1842
36 / 35
13.
* (14)
Eliza Roxcy SnowJune 29, 184236 / 38
14.Mrs. Sarah Rapson (Poulterer)after
July 1842
36 / 49
15.
* (15)
Sarah Ann WhitneyJuly 27, 184236 / 17
16.
(16)
Martha McBride (Knight)after
Aug. 5, 1842
36 / 37
17.
* (17)
Mrs. Ruth Daggett Vose (Sayers)Feb. 184337 / 35
18.
* (18)
Flora Ann WoodworthMar. 4, 184337 / 16
19.
* (19)
Emily Dow PartridgeMar. 4, 184337 / 19
20.
* (20)
Eliza Maria PartridgeMar. 8, 184337 / 22
21.
* (21)
Almera Wood[w]ard Johnsonafter
April 25, 1843
37 / 29
22.
* (22)
Lucy WalkerMay 1, 184337 / 17
23.
* (23)
Sarah LawrenceMay 11, 184337 / 16
24.
* (24)
Maria Lawrenceapprox.
May 1843
37 / 19
25.
* (25)
Helen Mar Kimballapprox.
May 1843
37 / 14
26.
* (27)
Mrs. Elvira Anna Cowles (Holmes)June 1, 184337 / 29
27.
* (28)
Rhoda RichardsJune 12, 184337 / 58
28.
* (26)
Hannah S. Ellsmid-184337 / 30
29.Mary Ann Frost (Stearns Pratt)July 24, 184337 / 34
30.
* (30)
Olive Grey Frostmid-184337 / 27
31.
* (32)
Nancy Maria Winchesterafter
mid-1843
37 / 14
32.
* (29)
Desdemona Catlin Wadsworth Fullmerafter
July 1843
37 / 33
33.
* (31)
Melissa LottSept. 20, 184337 / 19
34.Sarah Scott (Mulholland)after
Oct. 25, 1843
37 / 26
35.Mrs. Phebe Watrous (Woodworth)after
Oct. 29, 1843
37 / 38
36.Mary Hustonapprox.
Oct. 1843
37 / 25
37.
* (33)
Fanny Young (Carr Murray)Nov. 2, 184337 / 55

“What a thing it is for a man to be accused of committing adultery, and having seven wives, when I can only find one.”

Joseph Smith, (speaking of himself),
History of the Church, vol. 6, chp. 19, p. 411.
Engraving of Joseph Smith

Related reading:


Wives of Brigham Young

Portraits of Brigham Young’s wives
(click to view)


Chart of Brigham Young’s Wives

(See: “Determining and Defining ‘Wife’: The Brigham Young Households,” Jeffery Ogden Johnson, Dialogue: A Journal of Mormon Thought, 1987, vol. 20, no. 3, p. 64)

Marriage DateNameOther Husbands
1. — 1824 Oct. 8Miriam Works, 1806-32
2. — 1834 Feb. 10Mary Ann Angel, 1808-82
(Married during Joseph Smith’s life)
3. — 1842 June 14Lucy Ann Decker, 1822-90(1) William Seeley
4. — 1843 Nov. 2Augusta Adams, 1802-86(1) Henry Cobb
5. — 1843 Nov. 2Harriet Cook, 1824-98
6. — 1844 May 8Clarissa Decker, 1828-89

Married Before Completion of Nauvoo Temple

7. — 1844 Sept.Emily Dow Partridge, 1824-99(1) Joseph Smith
8. — 1844 Sept. 10Clarissa Ross, 1814-57
9. — 1844 Sept. 19Louisa Beaman, 1815-50(1) Joseph Smith
10. — 1844 Oct. 3Eliza Roxey Snow, 1804-87(1) Joseph Smith
11. — 1844 Oct. 3Elizabeth Fairchild, 1828-1910(2) James D. Lyman
(3) Joseph McMurray
(4) James Matthews
(5) W.L. Chastain
12. — 1844 Oct. 8Clarissa Blake, 1796-?
13. — 1844 Oct. 9Rebecca Holman, 1824-49
14. — 1844 Oct. 10Diana Chase, 1827-86(2) William M. Shaw
15. — 1844 Oct. 31Susannah Snively, 1815-92
16. — 1844 Nov. 7Olive Gray Frost, 1816-45
17. — 1845 Jan. 15Mary Ann Clark, 1816-?(1) Mr. Powers
18. — 1845 Jan. 16Margaret Pierce, 1823-1907(1) Morris Whitesides
19. — 1845 Jan. 16Mary Pierce, 1821-47
20. — 1845 April 30Emmeline Free, 1826-75
21. — 1845 May 22Mary Elizabeth Rollins, 1818-1913(1) Adam Lightner
(2) Joseph Smith

Married After Completion of Nauvoo Temple

22. — 1846 Jan. 14Margaret Alley, 1825-52
23. — 1846 Jan. 15Olive Andrews, 1818-?(1) Joseph Smith
24. — 1846 Jan. 15Emily Haws, 1823-?(1) William Whitmarsh
25. — 1846 Jan. 21Martha Bowker, 1822-90
26. — 1846 Jan. 21Ellen Rockwood, 1829-66
27. — 1846 Jan. 28Jemima Angel, 1803-69(1) Valentine Young
28. — 1846 Jan. 28Abigail Marks, 1781-1846(1) Asa Works
29. — 1846 Jan. 28Phebe Morton, 1776-1854(1) James W. Angel
30. — 1846 Jan. 28Cynthia Porter, 1783-?(1) Mr. Weston
31. — 1846 Jan. 31Mary Eliza Nelson, 1812-85(1) John P. Greene
(3) Bruce L. Philips
32. — 1846 Jan. 31Rhoda Richards, 1784-1879(1) Joseph Smith
33. — 1846 Feb. 2Zina Huntington, 1821-1901(1) Henry Jacobs
34. — 1846 Feb. 3Amy Cecilia Cooper, 1804-?(not known)
35. — 1846 Feb. 3Mary Ellen de la Montaigne, 1803-?(1) James B. Woodward
36. — 1846 Feb. 3Julia Foster, 1811-91(1) Jonathan Hampton
(3) Thomas Cole
37. — 1846 Feb. 3Abigail Harback, 1790-1849(1) Mr. Hall
38. — 1846 Feb. 3Mary Ann Turley, 1827-1904(2) John Cook
39. — 1846 Feb. 6Naamah Carter, 1821-1909(1) John S. Twiss
40. — 1846 Feb. 6Nancy Cressy, 1780-1872(1) Mr. Walker

Married While Crossing the Plains

41. — 1847 Feb. 10Jane Terry, 1819-47(1) George Tarbox
(2) George W. Young
42. — 1847 March 20Lucy Bigelow, 1830-1905
43. — 1847 March 20Mary Jane Bigelow, 1827-68(2) Horace Roberts
(3) Philander Bell
44. — 1848 April 18Sarah Malin, 1804-58

Married in Utah: 1850’s

45. — 1852 Oct. 3Eliza Burgess, 1827-1915
46. — 1852 Dec. 16Mary Oldfield, 1793-1875(1) Eli Kelsey
47. — before 1853Eliza Babcock, 1828-68(2) Dominicus Carter
(3) John Groves
48. — 1855 June 10Catherine Reese, 1804-60(1) Zepheniah Clawson
49. — 1856 March 14Harriet Barney, 1830-1911(1) W.H.H. Sagers

Married in Utah: 1860’s

50. — 1863 Jan. 24Amelia Folsom, 1838-1910
51. — 1865 Jan. 8Mary Van Cott, 1844-84(1) James T. Cobb
52. — 1868 April 7Ann Eliza Webb, 1844-?(1) James L. Dee
(3) Moses R. Deming
53. — 1869 July 3Elizabeth Jones, 1814-95(1) David T. Lewis
(2) Dan Jones

Married in Utah: 1870’s

54. – 1870 May 8Lydia Farnsworth, 1808-97(1) Elijah Mayhew
55. – 1872 Dec. 8Hannah Tapfield, 1807-86(1) Thomas O. King

Further reference: List of Brigham Young’s Wives (Wikipedia)

Illustration of Brigham Young

“The only men who become Gods, even the Sons of God, are those who enter into polygamy.”

Brigham Young,
Journal of Discourses, vol. 11, p. 269

Related reading:


Polygamy Among LDS Leadership and Percentage of Men and Women in Utah

The LDS church’s essay, “Plural Marriage and Families in Early Utah,” apparently tries to give the impression that large polygamous families were not common (and, by implication, not desired) among early Latter-day Saints, stating that:

Although some [LDS] leaders had large polygamous families, two-thirds of polygamist men had only two wives at a time.

Even in a society that has approximately equal numbers of men and women, one would hardly expect to see the practice of polygamy wide spread. Given the fact that the leaders had already taken the lion’s share of young women it is a wonder that the average Mormon man could find even one wife.2 If there had been sufficient opportunity it is easy to imagine those with fewer wives eagerly seeking more since, according to Brigham Young’s teaching, their future celestial glory depended on a vigorous participation in polygamy,3 and this indeed was what was being modeled to them by the church’s most prominent members (as seen in the list below).

The following list illustrates that most of the top LDS leadership followed Joseph Smith’s lead while still in Nauvoo, entering into polygamy before even going to Utah. Specifically, the list covers those who entered polygamy in Nauvoo and eventually had at least six wives.4

Prominent LDS Men and Their Wives


Brigham Young55 wives
Heber C. Kimball44 wives
Joseph Smith38 wives
John D. Lee19 wives
John Taylor18 wives
William Smith15 wives
Erastus Snow14 wives
Aaron Johnson12 wives
Franklin D. Richards12 wives

(11 wives each)

Joseph N. BatesWillard Richards
James Brown, Jr.George A. Smith
Parley P. PrattDaniel Wood

(10 wives each)

Samuel BenetOrson Pratt
William ClaytonW.H.H. Sagers
William A. HickmanWilford Woodruff
Isaac Morley

(9 wives each)

Dominicus CarterLorenzo Snow
Orson HydePhineas H. Young
Amasa M. Lyman

(8 wives each)

Ezra Taft BensonPeregrine Sessions
John L. ButlerJohn Smith
Charles R. DanaDaniel Spencer
Hiram DaytonNewel K. Whitney
Stephen MarkhamLorenzo D. Young
John Pack

(7 wives each)

James AllredIsaac Higbee
Ormus E. BatesBenjamin F. Johnson
John M. BernhiselCornelius P. Lott
Alpheus CutlerWilliam Miller
William DraperPhineas H. Richards
Elijah FordhamLucius N. Scovil
George D. Grant

(6 wives each)

John BenbowBenjamin T. Mitchell
Curtis E. BoltonW.W. Phelps
Frederick W. CoxCharles C. Rich
Charles CrismonJoseph L. Robinson
George P. DykesAbraham O. Smoot
Winslow Farr, Sr.Orson Spencer
Jacob GatesLevi Stewart
Thomas GroverChauncey G. Webb
Levi W. HancockEdwin D. Woolley
Eli B. KelseyThomas Woolsey
Chester LovelandJoseph Young

Related reading:

Footnotes:

  1. George D. Smith, Nauvoo Polygamy: “…but we called it celestial marriage, (Salt Lake City: Signature Books, 2008), pp. 621-23; Todd Compton, In Sacred Loneliness: The Plural Wives of Joseph Smith, (Salt Lake City: Signature Books, 1997), pp. 4-6; Andrew Jenson, ed., The Historical Record, “Plural Marriage,” vol. vi, (May 1887): pp. 233-34. ↩︎
  2. Indeed, evidence shows no surplus of women in the Utah Territory at this time, as John A. Widtsoe has observed:

    “The most common of these conjectures is that the Church, through plural marriage sought to provide husbands for its large surplus of female members. The implied assumption in this theory, that there have been more female than male members in the Church, is not supported by existing evidence. On the contrary, there seems always to have been more males than females in the Church. . . .
    “The United States census records from 1850 to 1940, and all available Church records, uniformly show a preponderance of males in Utah, and in the Church. Indeed, the excess in Utah has usually been larger than for the whole United States, . . .”

    John A. Widtsoe, Evidences and Reconciliations, arranged by G. Homer Durham, (Salt Lake City: Bookcraft, 1960), pp. 390-92. ↩︎
  3. Journal of Discourses, vol. 11, p. 269. ↩︎
  4. Smith, Nauvoo Polygamy, pp. 574-639. ↩︎

Discover more from Utah Lighthouse Ministry

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading